Clash of Judgments Over Teleworking Rights

On Tuesday 17th November 2026, the Contentious-Administrative Court No. 7 in Barcelona annulled a Generalitat instruction that banned teleworking for seven deputy general directors in the Department of Business and Labour. The ruling, delivered by Judge Benjamín Górriz, found that Instruction 1/2025, issued in January 2025 by the Minister for the Presidency Albert Dalmau, unlawfully overturned provisions set by Decree 77/2020, which allows telework for all personnel serving the Catalan administration. The judge ruled that the instruction 'clearly modifies' and 'innovates in the legal order' by eliminating remote work 'absolutely' for deputy directors and equivalent roles, thereby violating a higher-ranking administrative decree. As such, the court declared it 'null by law' due to breaching superior regulations. However, the court acknowledged it lacks jurisdiction to directly annul a general administrative provision. Instead, it has opened the way for an issue of illegality to be referred to the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC), which will ultimately decide on the legality of the ban.


Conflicting Ruling Days Earlier

This decision contrasts with a ruling issued just days earlier by Barcelona's Contentious-Administrative Court No. 14. On Monday 16th November 2026, Judge M. A. Llopis Vázquez rejected an appeal from 21 officials in the Department of Economy and Finance, upholding the Government's right to require physical presence for senior officials. The judge based her decision on the Government's powers of self-organisation, asserting that the Generalitat can demand continued physical presence from deputy general directors, the highest non-political tier in the civil service, as part of its internal management.

The instruction not only changed the telework regulations but also innovated the legal system by eliminating it absolutely for these roles.

The conflicting rulings mean that the legality of the remote work ban now hinges on the TSJC, which will be required to unify legal criteria and deliver a final, binding decision.


What It Means for Senior Officials

The dispute centres on whether a lower-level government instruction can override an existing decree. Decree 77/2020 established teleworking as a standard practice across the Catalan administration, but Instruction 1/2025 mandated in-person work for senior roles, including deputy general directors. Lawyer Benet Salellas, representing the seven officials, argued that the move was an overreach. The Government, meanwhile, maintains that senior officials require direct oversight. With the TSJC now set to resolve the contradiction, all affected officials must await a definitive legal stance on their right to work remotely.


Sources: elDiario.es, capitolab.es.